Add your business to ZipLeaf for free!
 United States Business Directory
Exploring the Legal Implications of Cohabitation: How South African law fails unmarried couples

By Property in Moot

Exploring the Legal Implications of Cohabitation: How South African law fails unmarried couples

12/17/2023 How does the law regulate the lives of those who live together but who are not married? The traditional civil marriage is no longer the only option available to couples in South Africa. Partners may decide to get married in terms of customary law or in terms of the Civil Unions Act or the Marriage Act. The law, however, has been slow to recognize the relationship of partners in a permanent cohabitation arrangement. https://www.propertyinmoot.co.za
Draft legislation in respect of domestic partnerships exists, but the Draft Partnership Bill has not been advanced since 2008. A domestic partnership is a relationship between two people who are living together, as though they are married, but are not. This will include relationships between same- and opposite-sex couples.
This gap in the law inevitably leads to a large portion of the population being excluded from the rights and obligations which naturally flow from a recognized marriage relationship, even if the people involved in the relationship act no differently toward each other than a married couple. It must be stated very clearly, that South African law does not recognize the concept of a common law marriage. No amount of time living together automatically translates to a marriage.
This shortcoming in the law usually only affects partners in permanent relationships at the dissolution of the relationship, whether it be by death or mutual decision. Especially where one partner passes away, the financial consequences involving inheritances and maintenance can turn especially tricky.
Many of the disadvantages alluded to above flow from the legal definition of the word ‘spouse’ and how it is defined in the pieces of legislation that govern inheritance and maintenance. The differentiation between married, unmarried, same-sex and opposite-sex partners has been the subject matter of many cases over the past few decades, as the Constitution provides that unfair discrimination based on marital status and sexual orientation is prohibited.
The word ‘spouse’ has been expanded several times to provide for people in different permanent relationships. For example, even though Islamic marriages are not formally recognized, the Intestate Succession Act provides that a spouse in an Islamic marriage is also included in the definition of ‘spouse’. The Estate Duty Act and the Income Tax Act also include permanent life partners, whether it be same-sex or opposite-sex, in the definition of ‘spouse.’
This article will briefly look at the impact of the provisions of the Intestate Succession Act on partners in a permanent relationship by way of the case of Bwanya v Master of the High Court, Cape Town and Others [2021] ZACC 51.
Ms Jane Bwanya lived with her partner in a permanent relationship. They were due to commence lobola negotiations and conclude a marriage, but unfortunately her partner passed before they could commence with the arrangements. Her partner left a will that nominated his mother as his only heir. However, his mother had predeceased him.
Ms Bwanya instituted 2 claims against her late partner’s estate – one for maintenance and the other for inheritance from his estate. Both claims were rejected by the executor of the estate, since Ms Bwanya was not considered to be a spouse to the deceased, as per the definition of spouse in the relevant legislation. She then challenged the constitutionality of the Acts in the High Court and was successful in her challenge of the Intestate Succession Act (ISA hereafter) in the High Court.
When the matter appeared before the Constitutional Court, Bwanya contented that the definition of ‘spouse’ in the ISA unfairly discriminates against her and others in her situation, based on the grounds of gender, marital status, and sexual orientation. She also argued that the ISA differentiates between surviving same-sex and opposite-sex life partners. This is due to the decision in the 2007 Constitutional Court case of Gory v Kolver, where the court ordered that the definition of ‘spouse’ be interpreted to include a partner in a permanent same-sex life partnership where the partners have undertaken reciprocal duties of support.
Madlanga J in the majority judgment emphasized that permanent life partnerships are a legitimate family structure and are deserving of respect and should be entitled to legal protection. The High Court’s declaration of invalidity of the definition in the ISA was confirmed. The Constitutional Court also recognized that the definition of ‘survivor’ in the Maintenance of Surviving Spouses Act was unconstitutional and invalid in so far as it excludes people in Ms Bwanya’s situation.
After this case, the surviving life partner in a permanent opposite-sex life partnership can inherit or claim maintenance if the partners undertook reciprocal duties of support to each other.
It is clear from the Bwanya case as well as those that came before it, that there is a general movement towards inclusivity towards all different kinds of relationships, regardless of whether the arrangement has been formally recognized by legislation. However, a practical hurdle exists in determining when exactly a relationship between two persons stops being casual and is intended to be permanent in the sense that it also attracts the rights and obligations naturally associated with a marriage relationship. In the case law examples that are available, all the couples were engaged or about to become engaged.
To make clear a couple’s intentions with regard to their life partner, it is of the utmost importance that an updated, valid will is available when a partner passes. This will prevent many heartbreaks and long legal battles regarding the interpretation of definitions. In an effort to be unambiguous and clearly set out the duties of the partners towards each other, a cohabitation agreement can also be drawn up.
Contact JJR Inc. to assist you with putting your affairs in order through proper estate planning. They also assist with notarial agreements of cohabitation.
This article is a general information sheet and should not be used or relied on as legal or other professional advice. No liability can be accepted for any errors or omissions nor for any loss or damage arising from reliance upon any information herein. Always contact your legal adviser for specific and detailed advice.
(Quoted from the source: https://jjrinc.co.za/28-february-2023/)

About This Author

Property in Moot

Property in Moot

We ensure that your property selling or buying experienceAt KW Team Diamond League–Moot, Pretoria, we prioritize the needs of our clients and the community. We offer 5-star service and professional photography, as well as data-driven valuations, to ensure that your property selling or buying exper…

Read More »

More Articles From This Author

Essential tips for property sellers in Rietfontein Pretoria

Essential tips for property sellers in Rietfontein Pretoria

01/06/2024 When prospective property buyers come to view your home, you may think it is more friendly to accompany them and chat while they walk around your property.However, most estate agents will advise you to keep a low profile in case you say the wrong thing at a critical point in the viewing process.Thei... Read More »

Tips before you putting your property in the market

Tips before you putting your property in the market

12/19/2023 Before putting your property in the market in Moot, Pretoria:Remember you don’t get a second chance to a first impression.Market valuation? Price correctly from the start, for a quicker and effortless sale. Remember the market is currently hyper price sensitive.Work with the right estate agent, Ke... Read More »

Property Market Overview in the Moot Area in Pretoria

Property Market Overview in the Moot Area in Pretoria

12/17/2023 The property market in the Moot area in Pretoria, South Africa is currently showing signs of stability. The average asking price for a property in the Moot is R1.5 million, which is slightly higher than the national average. However, the time it takes to sell a property has increased slightly, with... Read More »

How Does the Property Transfer Process Work in South Africa?

How Does the Property Transfer Process Work in South Africa?

12/17/2023 The property transfer process in South Africa can be complex and time-consuming, but it is important to understand the steps involved in order to ensure a smooth transaction. Step 1: Offer to purchaseThe first step in the property transfer process is for the buyer to make an offer to purchase the pr... Read More »

Answering Common Property Questions in the Vibrant Moot Area

Answering Common Property Questions in the Vibrant Moot Area

11/08/2023 Question 1: What are the most popular suburbs in the Moot area?Answer: The most popular suburbs in the Moot area are Rietfontein, Môregloed, Wonderboom South, Waverley, Queenswood and Villieria. These suburbs offer a wide range of properties, from apartments and townhouses to large detached houses.... Read More »

Finding the Best Property in the Pretoria Moot Area

Finding the Best Property in the Pretoria Moot Area

10/19/2023 When it comes to buying or selling property, estate agents play a crucial role in the process. However, not all estate agents are created equal. Commission is a sensitive topic in the real estate industry, as estate agents don’t have a fixed income and rely solely on commission. In this article, w... Read More »

The ups and downs of property co-ownership

The ups and downs of property co-ownership

10/19/2023 Property ownership is no small feat. It is one of the most reliable forms of investment and one of the biggest items that most people have on their financial “to-do” lists. Unfortunately, it is not always an easily achievable goal. Property ownership has always been a costly endeavour, and in re... Read More »

Selling a property with defects: What you need to know

Selling a property with defects: What you need to know

10/07/2023 The Purchaser signs an agreement of sale with the Seller. The property is transferred into the Purchaser’s name. A month later, there were heavy rainfalls and the roof leaks. Is the Property Seller liable to repair the roof or the Purchaser, as the new owner?To understand which party is liable, on... Read More »

The Property Seller can be held liable if the latent defect existed

The Property Seller can be held liable if the latent defect existed

10/07/2023 The Purchaser signs an agreement of sale with the Seller. The property is transferred into the Purchaser’s name. A month later, there were heavy rainfalls and the roof leaks. Is the Property Seller liable to repair the roof or the Purchaser, as the new owner?To understand which party is liable, on... Read More »

Real Estate Success with Keller Williams: Buying Strategies

Real Estate Success with Keller Williams: Buying Strategies

10/07/2023 When diving into the realm of real estate and property acquisitions, discerning the nuances between a conditional and a clean offer can be pivotal. A clean offer is the beacon of attraction for property sellers, carrying minimal pre-conditions, showcasing your unwavering commitment. Conversely, a co... Read More »

Important Rules to Know Before Buying Property in a Complex or Estate in South Africa

Important Rules to Know Before Buying Property in a Complex or Estate in South Africa

10/07/2023 The popularity of gated communities and estates has increased in South Africa due to the added security they provide to homeowners.A recent poll showed that out of 4,000 respondents, 1,500 live in a gated community, while 2,500 do not.The shift to remote working from home has further increased deman... Read More »